Type a shoe name, like Pegasus, Clifton or Kayano.

Montrail Columbia Caldorado

Trail shoe · Neutral · Trail · 10.2 oz (men's) · 8mm drop

Discontinued — we no longer see this shoe in stock.

How it ranks

The Montrail Columbia Caldorado’s rating is an early estimate. We’ve collected 1 runner review so far, with brand history also informing the score.

Current estimate: Decent

74
Overall
74
Comfort
81
Value
76
Durability
73
Appearance
73
Cushioning
70
Confidence

Confidence

How settled the rating is against every other rated shoe. A shoe can rate high on confidence with relatively few reviews of its own when its product line has a long record and external ratings from retailer sites agree. Confidence is low when we have few ratings or when runners disagree.

Confidence

19 Very low

19

Based on

The bars show roughly how much each source contributes to this shoe’s rating. Their influence depends on how many reviews we’ve collected, how many earlier versions are in the product line, and the external ratings available.

  1. Brand rating
  2. Our ratings
  3. External ratings

Where to buy

No offers available

Affiliate links included. They never affect our ratings.

Prices updated daily. Last checked Oct 22.

Pros

  • The one reviewer so far has 200 miles on a pair with hardly any visible wear and calls it sure footed.

Cons

  • Durability draws 3 out of 5 in the single review so far, its lowest mark.

Rating & Confidence vs. other shoes for sale

Each dot is one rated shoe for sale, placed by its rating and by how much evidence sits behind it. Shoes toward the top right are both well rated and well established.

Confidence
50 60 70 80 90 100 25 50 75 100

Better Shoes Rating

Columbia Caldorado rates 74. This shoe has very low confidence. See how we rate shoes.

Runner Ratings

1 rating
5/5 0
4/5 1
3/5 0
2/5 0
1/5 0
See written reviews Write a review

Specs & fit

Sizing and ride details at a glance.

Weight
10.2 oz (men's)
Release
2017 Q3
MSRP
$120
Drop
8mm

Runner reviews

Write a review

Showing 1–1 of 1 written review

Caldorado rocks

4/5

Overall

I'm finding this a good shoe so far. I have 200 miles on them and there is hardly any visible wear or breakdown. They are sure footed on sloppy trails, fit my feet, and so far aren't giving blisters.

runs4cache · Dec 27, 2017

45 mpw training for ultramarathons

Comfort
4/5
Durability
3/5
Appearance
4/5
Value
4/5

Alternatives

Other shoes worth considering.

Nike Wildhorse 10

Wildhorse 10

Trail shoe

92 Very good

$93
Nike ACG Pegasus Trail

ACG Pegasus Trail

Trail shoe

92 Very good

$93
The North Face VECTIV Enduris 4

VECTIV Enduris 4

Trail shoe

90 Very good

$113
Nike ACG Zegama Trail

ACG Zegama Trail

Trail shoe

84 Good

$100
Topo Athletic Ultraventure 5

Ultraventure 5

Trail shoe

90 Very good

$155
Nike ACG Ultrafly Trail

ACG Ultrafly Trail

Trail shoe

83 Good

$141

Compared to other shoes

See how this shoe compares to others like it.

Shoe image placeholder
Nike ACG Pegasus Trail
HOKA Bondi 8
Columbia Caldorado
ACG Pegasus Trail
Bondi 8
Current shoe
Choose a model
Reference shoe
Lightest / Newest / Lowest price
Best overall / Best comfort / Best cushioning
Shoe properties
Type
Trail shoe
Trail shoe
Daily trainer
Pronation
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Weight
10.2 oz (men's)
9.7 oz Lightest
9.9 oz
Stack
—
—
40/35mm
Drop
8mm
8mm
4mm
Release
2017 Q3
2026 Q2 Newest
2022 Q3
MSRP
$120
$155
$165
Best price
—
$93 Lowest price
$95
Ratings
Overall
74 Decent
92 Very good
99 Exceptional Best overall
Comfort
81 Good
79 Decent
99 Exceptional Best comfort
Cushioning
70 Decent
77 Decent
99 Exceptional Best cushioning
Durability
73 Decent
85 Good
97 Exceptional Best durability
Appearance
73 Decent
95 Excellent Best appearance
75 Decent
Value
76 Decent
84 Good Best value rating
77 Decent
Specific shoe

Search for the exact model to add to this comparison.